468x60 PDD Banner Ad

filed under City Hall | Rhody | evolution

What’s in a Name?

8:21PM ON 06/26/2009
BY Kevin Reardon

I was checking out the old Internet today and I made my way to a weblog that rhymes with duffington coast. Right square in the middle of their politics page I noticed that Rhode Island had an article written about it. Apparently the Rhode Island House on Thursday voted on a referendum on taking the “and Providence Plantations” out of “Rhode Island and Providence Plantations”. It made it through the Senate on Friday. I am going to stay out of the PC/tradition argument, but since we have until 2010 for both sides to make their all too predictable cases about the situation, it will certainly be interesting to watch.

Here is the Projo article.

One Comment on “ What’s in a Name? ”

  1. Historically, the name originally combined the names of two previously separate settlements under a single charter. In modern parlance, it would be “Greater Newport and Greater Providence.” If there’s a good reason for dropping the second part, it’s that it’s hardly ever used anyway, and everyone here calls the big island Aquidneck, so there’s no confusion.

    The term ‘plantation’ predates American slavery, and in fact America itself. It has no exact definition, but typically refers to a commercial monoculture. A modern large wheat farm is a kind of plantation, and so is a planted timber field. There remain many modern-day plantations in the U.S., many of which accurately use the term. It’s also used in some placenames (such as Plantation, Florida).

    Rhode Island has much to answer for historically regarding slavery, but the use of the term ‘plantations’ in the name is not part of our history of slavery. It referred to the largely agrarian settlement that existed at the head of the bay at the time. And definitely not to slavery, because Roger Williams founded the settlement on several precepts one of which was abolition. That later Rhode Islanders took to slavery and the slave trade is a deeply regrettable but historically unrelated coincidence.

    My problem with the attack on this part of our name is that besides being historically misplaced, it’s politically misplaced. It’s as if people honestly believe that by eradicating the word, we can eradicate the reality. We obviously cannot. But supposing that we somehow could, where should we stop? We can freely associate many different words, ideas, symbols, concepts, and other historical elements such as songs and other artworks with slavery. Slavery was, after all, a very big part of this nation’s history, and of this state’s as well. We could pick off one or another word or other thing here or there, but what would it change?

    A symbol assigned to a thing, for any reason, is not the thing itself. The word ‘plantation’ has been used far more extensively than in context of slavery, and it never meant that in this state. To remove it is to take away a part of our heritage, and it would probably mollify some people, but it inadvertently invests a previously innocent usage with a powerful history it never possessed.

    If we’re unable to separate the word from the history, then how can we ever process and overcome the scars of that history? We can take the word off the name, but we can’t kick a word out of the language, or the history of a language, or the language of history. So at that it becomes simply pointless, and wasteful.

    Show me one shred of evidence connecting “Providence Plantations” with slavery, and I will support this change. Otherwise, I’d advise people to remember that words are only tools, not the actions of people who use them.

    Reply

Write a Comment

ARCHIVES:

CATEGORIES:

Add to Technorati Favorites

What Cheer! Antiques

side blog «contribute now!»

» Will plastic be okay?

For those of us that don’t live in the city, we’re not…

» The Theatre of Education Reform

U.S. Secretary of Education, Arne Duncan, announced Rhode Island’s acceptance into the…

» Marriage Equality at the State House

Today a huge, enthusiastic crowd braved the cold to rally for the…

» Party at Everyman Bistro

Providence, the birthplace of the diner, will go nationwide Monday when the…

» “Burning building? Call 9-1-1. Burning Question? Call 3-1-1.”

Lost your pet? You’re going to need to find the number for…

» Walking With Dinosaurs

Walking With Dinosaurs
June 23 - 27, 2010
Wed - Fri 7pm…

» Monday! Monday! Monday!

NO RI VeloSprints on Monday!
It’s President’s Day so, celebrate the great…

» Jesse Liam CD Release Celebration

WHEN? Saturday, March 6th 7:00-10pm
COST? FREE!!!
WHERE? Cantina di Marco Restaurant…

VIEW ALL SIDE-BLOG POSTS

POPULAR TAGS

RECENT COMMENTS

9:59AM 03/16/2010
H. said:

So what's the deal with this place? Is it related to the Liquid Lounge?...

about Not Yet

4:50AM 03/16/2010
Huds said:

FOX as a hard-core porn channel. And England saving our asses in WWIII....

about This Friday: The Future of the Simpsons

12:12AM 03/16/2010
Dave Segal said:

soy ice cream vending machines....

about This Friday: The Future of the Simpsons

5:04PM 03/15/2010
Andy said:

Forget Goofing Around: Recess Has a New Boss NYT.com / March 14, 2010 http://www.nytimes.com/2010/03/15/education/15recess.html?scp=1&sq=recess&st=cse...

about What Is Missing From This Picture?

12:50PM 03/15/2010
Craig said:

There will be a free raffle and a chocolate tasting...what the heck else could you ask for?...

about Urban Greens Member Drive

10:11PM 03/14/2010
Dave Segal said:

No GC:PVD this year? Guess I'm stuck voting for us again....

about Because Dose Readers Are The Best Readers In The World

10:09AM 03/14/2010
David Evans said:

If I lived in Texas, I would be begging for national standards. As a RI high school science teacher, I see...

about Everything You Need to Know

10:52PM 03/12/2010
Toby Shepherd said:

With all due respect, I totally disagree with your post - common core standards are a GREAT step in the...

about Everything You Need to Know