Archive for the ‘ justice ’ Category

filed under: First Amendment | justice

Segal Opinion Piece At Politico On Aaron Swartz Case

8AM ON 29/08/2013
BY Beth Comery

Aaron Swartz Boston Wikipedia.jpg.CROP.rectangle3-large David Segal has written an excellent piece at Politico “What killed Aaron Swartz?” summarizing the circumstances surrounding Swartz’s suicide and bringing us up to date on the case. The news regarding the Justice Department is depressing as always. Dave highlights one detail, the importance of which was not previously understood.

With my help, he started an Internet petition in support of the little guy — this time, himself. And according to the report MIT recently released about its role in the prosecution, that petition, as it met the authoritarianism and petty vindictiveness of U.S. Attorney Carmen Ortiz and her deputies, might have effectively cost Aaron his life.

Dave was the co-creator with Swartz of the online advocacy group Demand Progress — Internet petitions play a large role in their campaigns and should of course enjoy First Amendment protection. House Oversight and Government Reform Committee Chairman Darrell Issa found this new information troubling enough to demand a new briefing from Attorney General Eric Holder, and Senators John Cornyn and Al Franken have secured a new briefing on the case in the spring. It’s not over.

(Photo by Phil Stearns)

Providence Daily Dose co-creator David Segal is also executive director of Demand Progress, a civil liberties and government reform activist group with more than 1.5 million members. He was previously a Providence city councilman, Rhode Island state representative, and congressional candidate in Rhode Island.

filed under: justice |

Aaron Swartz Vs. The Justice Department

2PM ON 21/01/2013
BY Beth Comery

federal courthouse The Providence Journal has weighed in on the Aaron Swartz tragedy. In recent columns, both the editorial board and columnist Froma Harrop focused their attention on the “stealing is stealing” issue.

Harrop (1.20.13) asks us to compare the outcry at the excessive prosecution of Aaron Swartz to the lonely plight of a “street kid ripping off copper pipes,” writing,

What we hear is the voice of privilege: Sensitive Ivy Leaguers are to be treated more gently than thugs caught prying radios out of cars. (Anyone interested in the mental state of the drug-addled dropout?)

(Short answer: Yes. For years the members of LEAP have been very interested.)

But this is comparing apples to oranges; let’s stick with violations enforced by the federal authorities.

Law enforcement agencies and prosecutors across the country are constantly forced to prioritize their cases, allocate resources, and focus their efforts on crimes posing the greatest threat to the citizenry. So how is it that the Justice Department landed with both feet on Aaron Swartz ( he faced a potential 35 years in prison) while giving the Wall Street bankers who nearly destroyed our economy a complete pass?

The Providence Journal editorial (1.18.13) concluded,

What he is accused of was definitely a crime. And as the Massachusetts U.S. attorney’s office no doubt understood, to let cybercrimes go unpunished threatens the nation’s economy by removing incentives for creative work.

Threats to the nation’s economy? Matt Taibbi’s piece in the latest Rolling Stone“Secrets and Lies of the Bailout” — details a much greater threat to our economy. The megabanks are now bigger than ever and jam-packed with risk. And could there be a greater threat to our economy than having the Justice Department — when several banks admitted to years of laundering money for drug cartels and terroristsofficially declaring that these banks are now “too big to prosecute.”

Tomorrow night (Tuesday at 10pm) PBS Frontline will air “The Untouchables.” Learn how more than four years since the financial crisis, not one senior Wall Street executive has faced criminal prosecution for fraud. Compare their wrongdoing and special treatment to what was thrown at Aaron Swartz and ask yourself, “Who was the vulnerable ’street kid’ in this scenario?”



Add to Technorati Favorites

side blog «contribute now!»

» More NFL Bad Lip Reading

At least watch till the Peyton Manning bit. And Belichick.

» Top Honors For Making Things Christmas-y Go To . . .

We don’t know. Who does this? Once again the corner of this…

» RISD Holiday Alumni Art Sale

Open till 5pm . . . head down to the RI Convention…

» Happy Birthday H. P. Lovecraft

Born August 20, 1890. This newly dedicated square is at Prospect and…

» Wayland Square Street Event

Be advised Wayland Avenue is blocked off to traffic between Angell and…

» Never A Boast Or A Brag

James Cagney performs “You’re a Grand Old Flag” from the movie “Yankee…

» Music Inspired By Sarah Whitman At Athenaeum

The Providence Athenaeum presents “Volumes of Forgotten Lore” a musical program inspired…

» Happy Holidays Providence

Nicely done City Hall — this is a handsome tree, densely spangled…